3 BR, 2 BA, Maximum Occupancy: 8
134 West Ave, Eagle Bay, NY 13331
Herkimer County

Old Forge Region Vacation Rentals — LISTING ID: VR12456

Owner's Contact Information

(704) 231-5496    |   SEND OWNER AN EMAIL INQUIRY

100+ year old 2 story Log Cabin originally built as the residence of the founder of Eagle Bay. Relax in an open great room with sky light and stone fireplace. At the end of the day, retreat to one of three cozy bedrooms located up an open winding staircase. Spend time on the oversized porch overlooking a private corner lot. Start your day on the back patio with a coffee and doughnut from the Doughnut shop just up the street. Enjoy the cool summer nights on a second stone patio with large firepit and picnic table. Two full bathrooms, one in the cabin and a second with washer and dryer in an adjacent bunkhouse. We are a short walk down the hill to take advantage of access to the Eagle Bay Private swim area. Located just down the street from the Tavern and the Eagle Bay House and a short drive to Inlet (1.5 miles) or Old Forge (8 miles).


Owner's Contact Information

(704) 231-5496
Send owner an email inquiry
Email this listing to a friend
Print This Listing

– Check Availability –

Listed with Adirondack "By Owner" since 2021.

This property listing is an advertisement. Please read this IMPORTANT NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER for more information.


weekly rentals only. $2.250.00. Half due at time of rental and remaining balance due 30 days prior to check in date.

Listing ID: VR12456
Property Address: 134 West Ave, Eagle Bay, NY 13331 - ADDRESS MAP
Region: Old Forge Region
Bedrooms: 3
Bed Sizes: 3 Queen, 1 Twin, 1 Futon,
Bathrooms: 2
Max Occupancy: 8
Pet Policy: Pets will be considered on a case by case basis and will incur a separate pet fee.
Smoking Policy: Absolutely no smoking
Cleaning Policy: Although we will have the cabin cleaned between guests, we expect you to leave the cabin in the condition you found it. All trash must be removed, refrigerator emptied and wiped down, dishes washed and stored, kitchen and bath wiped down and floors vacuumed.
Linen Policy: You will need to provide your own linens including sheets (4 queen including futon and 1 twin), hand towels, bath towels, washcloths, and beach towels. Pillows, mattress pads, blankets, and kitchen towels will be provided.
Security Deposit Information: A security deposit of $500.00 (payable to secure reservation) will be required and will be returned within 30 days of your departure less any damages, repairs, or excessive cleaning charges. Non refundable in the event of cancelation.


  • 100% Smoke Free (no indoor smoking ever by owners or renters)
  • Adirondack Chairs
  • Antique Furnishings
  • Beach, Association or Shared
  • Cable TV Reception, Basic
  • Coffee Maker
  • Dryer
  • Fan (ceiling)
  • Fan (portable)
  • Fire Pit
  • Fireplace (wood burning)
  • Grill (gas)
  • High Speed Internet - Wireless
  • Ironing Board/Iron
  • Kitchenware (dishes, pots, utensils, etc.)
  • Lake Access (easy walk)
  • Microwave
  • Pets Considered
  • Picnic Table, Outdoor
  • Porch (screen)
  • Refrigerator/Freezer (full size)
  • Rustic Furnishings
  • Stove/Oven
  • Television, Luxury
  • Toaster
  • Tourist Information Folder
  • Walk to Town
  • Walk-In Closet
  • Washer


Activities 1-15 Minutes

  • Airplane Tour
  • Amusement Park
  • Antique Shopping
  • Arcade
  • ATM (Cash) Machine
  • Bank
  • Bar/Tavern/Brew Pub
  • Basketball Court
  • Bike Path
  • Bike Rentals
  • Boat Rentals
  • Boat Tour
  • Boating
  • Canoe/Kayak Rentals
  • Canoeing/Kayaking
  • Church
  • Farmer's Market
  • Fishing
  • Fitness Club
  • Gas Station
  • Go-Karts
  • Golf Course
  • Grocery Store - Small
  • Hiking Trail(s)
  • Horse Trails
  • Horseback Riding Center
  • Lake
  • Laundromat
  • Library
  • Marina
  • Miniature Golf
  • Mountain Bike Center
  • Movie Rental Store
  • Movie Theatre
  • Playground
  • Private Beach
  • Public Beach
  • Public Boat Launch
  • Restaurant
  • Sailing
  • Scenic Ski Lift or Gondola Ride
  • Tennis
  • Train Ride
  • Urgent or Emergency Care Center
  • Walking Path
  • Water Park

Activities 31-60 Minutes

  • Hospital
  • Museum
  • Nature Center or Attraction

Meet the Owner(s)

About Us: This cabin has been in my family for 40+ years. Prior to that, we rented from the previous owner for 10+ years. In addition to having the privilege of spending my summers here, I have raised my family here as well. While we currently still enjoy it and the area, we decided to open it up for renters for part of the season to allow others to experience a taste of authentic Adirondack life. When not enjoying the cabin there, we live just shy of an hour away and personally maintain the property.

Why we think you will enjoy staying in Eagle Bay: Eagle Bay is conveniently located just 8 miles north of Old Forge and 1.5 miles shy of Inlet on 4th Lake. You will find several hiking trails and modest mountain climbs within a very short drive. Both Inlet and Old Forge offer a variety of shopping options as well as many dining establishments to choose from, whether it is wings and Pizza or a fine dining experience that you are looking for.

Why our property is special: As described, our cabin was built by and for the founder of Eagle Bay. As soon as you walk in, you are met with the unmistakable charm of an authentic Adirondack Cabin. It sits on one of the largest lots in Eagle Bay Park and offers both privacy and convenience.




Owner's Contact Information

(704) 231-5496    |   SEND OWNER AN EMAIL INQUIRY

This property listing is an advertisement. Please read this IMPORTANT NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER for more information.

– Check Availability – Print This Listing Email This Listing to a Friend
Back to Your Search Results All Vacation Rentals in the Old Forge Region New Vacation Rentals Search All Last Minute Specials